A Serious Problem That Invalidates The 'Dimensional' Subtype Of Focus

 Martin, Matthiessen & Painter (2010: 170):

The Focus element can have a range of functions, which are outlined in Table 5.7 below.

Blogger Comments:

To be clear, not one of examples of the 'dimensional' subtype of Focus is a nominal group with the Head and Thing out of phase. That is, in every single case, the Head conflates with Thing:

This can be demonstrated by the fact the Head is also the entity that functions as participant in the transitivity system (Halliday & Matthiessen 2014: 394). For example, the Head element is the Thing to which Attributes are assigned:

The size of X is enormous.

The shape of X is irregular.

The colour of X is crimson.

The height of X is 2 m.

The weight of X is 4 kg.

The length of X is 40 km.

The texture of X is silky smooth.

The taste of X is like syrup.

The smell of X is like coal gas.

The nose of X is floral.

The aroma of X is fragrant.

The feel of X is unpleasant.

The look of X is modern.

The sound of X is mellifluous.